Tenant Screening

Tenant Screening for Landlords

How rental tenant screening works, what a tenant background check covers, and how to evaluate every applicant fairly — with a workflow that keeps the decision and the paperwork together.

Get Started Or talk to our team

Quick Answers

Tenant screening with Prop Companion, in brief

Does Prop Companion screen tenants?

It gives landlords a consistent screening workflow rather than a one-click background check. Applicants apply against your listing; you review each one against criteria you set in advance, approve or decline, and the application, your decision and the automatic applicant notification are all kept together on file. The approval decision is always yours — on the higher plan, the team also helps vet applicants and onboard approved tenants.

What is Prop Companion?

Prop Companion is AI-powered property management software for rental owners. Rent collection, tenant screening, leasing, maintenance and vendor work orders run from one web dashboard. It is a tool the owner operates — not a management company that takes over the property — and it is based in Dallas, Texas, serving the Dallas–Fort Worth metroplex.

Who is it for?

Independent landlords with one rental or a small portfolio, and real estate investors managing several properties. Tenants and maintenance vendors each get their own portal, but the property owner is the account holder and makes every decision.

What does it cost?

A flat monthly fee per property — billed month to month, with no setup fee, no long-term contract and no percentage taken from rent. There are two plans: a base plan for owners who self-manage, and a higher plan that adds hands-on leasing help. Current prices are on the pricing page, and portfolios above ten units are quoted individually.

Does it collect rent?

Yes. Tenants pay rent online through their portal and the funds route to the owner’s connected account, processed through Stripe by card or US bank transfer. Payment status and history show in the owner’s dashboard.

How does maintenance work?

A tenant describes the problem in plain language. The AI maintenance assistant identifies the category, gives safe do-it-yourself steps and is available at any hour. If that does not resolve it, the system drafts a work order and routes it to a vendor. The owner approves the quote and the cost before work goes ahead, and Prop Companion adds no markup to vendor invoices.

How is it different from traditional property management?

A traditional property manager takes over the property and usually charges 8–12% of monthly rent plus separate leasing and renewal fees. Prop Companion is software the owner runs for a flat per-property fee, with the owner approving every applicant, repair and expense. The higher plan adds optional hands-on leasing and turnover help, but control stays with the owner.

Overview

Why screening is the highest-leverage decision a landlord makes

A vacant unit costs you a few weeks of rent. The wrong tenant can cost months — missed payments, property damage, and in the worst case an eviction that ties up the unit and your time. Rental tenant screening is how you shift that risk before you hand over the keys, and it only works when it is consistent: the same checks, the same standards, and the same documentation for every applicant.

This page walks through the full process, what belongs in a tenant background check, the rules that govern how you use the results, and how Prop Companion keeps it all in one dashboard alongside rent collection and AI-assisted maintenance. If you're weighing it up, the plan comparison shows exactly what each tier covers.

The Process

How rental tenant screening works, step by step

Six stages take an applicant from “interested” to an approved, documented decision.

Application and written consent

Collect a complete application — full legal name, date of birth, current address, employer, and prior landlords — plus signed authorization to run a background and credit check. Nothing else can start until consent is on file.

Identity verification

Confirm the applicant is who they say they are with a government ID and a match against the name, date of birth, and Social Security number on the application. This prevents someone from screening under a clean identity that isn’t theirs.

Credit check

Pull the full credit report, not just the score. Look at payment history, current debt load, collections, and any accounts tied to housing. A soft-style rental inquiry does not damage the applicant’s score.

Background and eviction history

Check for prior evictions, housing-court judgments, and criminal records that are legally reportable in your jurisdiction. Rules on what you can consider — and how far back — vary by state and city, so apply a written policy rather than a gut call.

Income and rental history

Verify income with pay stubs, an offer letter, or bank statements, and confirm it against a rent-to-income standard you set in advance (many landlords use 3× monthly rent). Call the last two landlords — not just the current one, who may want the tenant to leave.

Decision, notification, and records

Approve or decline against your written criteria. Notify the applicant either way, and if the report drove a denial or different terms, send an adverse action notice. Keep the application, consent, report summary, and your reasoning together.

Tenant Background Checks

What a tenant background check should cover

Each item answers a different question about how the tenancy is likely to go.

Identity

Is the applicant really the person on the application, and is the SSN and date of birth theirs?

Credit & debt

Do they pay obligations on time, and how much of their income is already committed to debt?

Eviction history

Have they been formally evicted or taken to housing court before, and how recently?

Reportable records

Are there criminal records that your written, jurisdiction-compliant policy allows you to consider?

Income & employment

Is verified income stable and high enough for the rent under the ratio you set beforehand?

Rental references

Did previous landlords get paid on time, get the unit back in good shape, and would they rent again?

Benefits

What consistent screening does for landlords

The upside compounds over the life of every tenancy.

Fewer missed payments

Verified income and a clean payment history are the strongest predictors that rent shows up on time.

Lower eviction risk

Catching a pattern of prior evictions before signing avoids a process that can cost thousands and months.

Shorter vacancies

A defined checklist lets you say yes to a strong applicant quickly instead of second-guessing.

Fairer, more defensible decisions

Written criteria applied the same way to everyone protect both the applicant and you.

A complete paper trail

Application, consent, results, and reasoning in one place if a decision is ever questioned.

Better long-term tenants

Renters who clear a thorough process tend to renew, look after the place, and communicate.

Screen Everyone the Same Way

The rules that govern how you use the results

Running a tenant background check is regulated. Staying inside the lines is mostly about process, not legal expertise:

Get written consent before requesting any consumer report.

Set your criteria in writing before you list the unit.

Apply the identical standard to every applicant.

Send an adverse action notice when a report drives a denial.

Never decide based on a protected class under fair housing law.

Keep records of what you checked and why you decided.

This is general information, not legal advice. State and local rules on credit, criminal history, and income vary — check the law where your rental is located.

In Prop Companion

Where screening lives in your dashboard

Prop Companion doesn’t bolt screening on as a separate tool — it’s part of the same workflow as the rest of the tenancy:

Applications come in against your listing

Interested renters apply to a specific unit, so every application arrives with context instead of as a loose email.

Approve or decline in one click

Record your decision from Dashboard → My Tenants. Approved renters get a welcome email; declined applicants are notified automatically.

Documents stay on file

The application and your decision are kept with the tenant record, so your paper trail is one click away.

Onboarding picks up automatically

An approved tenant moves straight into lease setup, deposit, and online rent collection — no re-keying.

Ready to run screening this consistently?

One flat monthly fee per property — screening, leases, rent and maintenance all in the same dashboard.

See Plans & Pricing Built for landlords like you →

FAQ

Tenant screening FAQs

Common questions from landlords running their own screening.

Tenant screening is the process a landlord uses to review a rental applicant before signing a lease. It usually combines an application, identity verification, a credit check, a background and eviction-history check, and confirmation of income and past rental history. The goal is to decide — consistently and on documented criteria — whether an applicant is likely to pay rent on time and follow the lease.

A complete rental background check typically covers identity, credit history and current debts, criminal records where legally reportable, prior evictions or housing-court judgments, employment and income, and references from previous landlords. Which items you can use, and how, is governed by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and by state and local law.

When an applicant submits a complete application and gives consent, the automated parts of a background check — credit, records, eviction history — often return within minutes to a day. Landlord references and employment verification usually take one to three business days because they depend on people responding. Building a clear checklist ahead of time is the main way to keep the whole process to under a week.

No. Under the FCRA you must get the applicant’s written authorization before requesting a consumer report, tell them a report may be used in the decision, and — if you decline them or set different terms because of something in the report — send an adverse action notice naming the reporting agency. Prop Companion keeps the application, consent, and your decision together so this paper trail is easy to produce.

There is no single required number. Many landlords look for a score in the mid-600s or above, but score alone is a weak signal — a thin file, medical debt, or a recent move can pull it down for an otherwise reliable renter. Read the full report: rent-to-income ratio, payment history, collections, and prior evictions tell you more than the headline score.

Write your criteria down before you list the unit — minimum income, acceptable credit range, how you treat past evictions or criminal records — and apply the exact same standard to every applicant. Never make decisions based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status, or disability. Keep records of what you checked and why you decided as you did.

Prop Companion gives you the structure to run screening consistently: applicants apply against your listing, you record your criteria and results in one place, approve or decline with automatic email notifications to the applicant, and keep every document on file. On the PRO plan you also get hands-on leasing assistance, including help moving approved tenants through onboarding.

Once you approve a tenant in your dashboard, they receive a welcome email and move into onboarding — lease details, deposit, and move-in steps. Declined applicants are notified automatically, so you never have to send an awkward manual email. From there, Prop Companion handles rent collection, maintenance requests, and work orders in the same place.

More questions about how the platform works? Read the full FAQ · Guides on the blog

Keep Exploring

Ready to screen tenants with less guesswork?

Run every applicant through the same consistent, documented process — approve or decline in one click.

Get Started Today Contact Us

No setup fee · Cancel anytime